Eyes Off Saint Paul conducted interviews via video with both candidate for the open seat on the Ramsey County board of supervisors. We wanted to get the candidates on record with their views on the use of AI-enabled mass surveillance technology by law enforcement. The interview with Rebecca Noecker was conducted on October 15 and that with Maria Isa Pérez Vega on Octobrt 30.
Here are links to transcripts of the full interviews: Noecker, Pérez Vega.
| Question | Rebecca Noecker |
María Isa Pérez-Vega |
|---|---|---|
| Push for accountability and regulation of surveillance technology? |
✅ | ✅ |
| Pull back on use of Flock and other technologies at the county level? |
✅ | ✅ |
| Address all vendors not just Flock? | ✅ | ✅ |
| Seek input and engagement from the community? |
✅ | ✅ |
Q: What is your personal opinion on the need for, or the role and scope of, surveillance technologies used by law enforcement?
María Isa Pérez-Vega —
“I’ve had conversations [with local, county, and state law enforcement departments] regarding my experiences as being a young woman of color growing up being surveilled due to my work in community organizing and activism, due to the intense police violence that I have been a victim in community of before even knowing what the word activism meant as a child, and bringing those lived experiences into what does surveillance overall mean for our overall safety, and what’s keeping us safe, and what are those relationships being built from the actual public, the actual people, and how that engages with the leaders of law enforcement and these individual departments.”
“My focus has been working with the leads in the state departments of Public Safety to ensuring that technology doesn’t disproportionately threaten our communities that are being surveilled. But there’s also these, you know, what are the pros? What are the cons? And the pros in some of those advocacy where we are hoping that the data isn’t leaked right? But is, for example a woman named Kari who was killed in broad daylight while she was painting a mural in my Lowertown community of District 65B, and she was shot and killed in the back of her head with no conscious of somebody doing that. It was a surveillance camera that detected the license plate…So we know that if we did not have access to that technology, we wouldn’t have found the killer, but that technology, if that’s the pro, what are the cons, right? The cons are that there’s a lot of these same technology uses of cameras that are not protecting our most vulnerable populations.”
Rebecca Noecker —
“Public safety and public trust are inextricably connected. We know that because in St. Paul, we have a really strong separation ordinance, which me made even stronger during Metro Surge, and that is an ordinance that is strongly backed by our police, fire department, and our emergency response department because they know that if people aren’t going to call 911, if they’re afraid to call 911 because they don’t trust law enforcement, because they think their data might be shared with the federal government or for any other reason, everyone is less safe.”
“Surveillance technology always needs to be balanced with the trust that if it makes us safer as a technology, if it could objectively make us safer, it’s not going to if people don’t trust it. So that’s where I think government is so important, where guardrails are so important, to make sure that technology is actually making us safer, both on the technology side and on the trust side.”
Q: Aside from Flock Cameras, what other mass surveillance technologies would you work to end the use of?
María Isa Pérez-Vega —
“A large part of my role has been on advocating for strong restrictions and accountability for governments’ uses of surveillance and technologies, protecting residents and overseeing a public oversight of surveillance and transparency when these negotiations, whether it is Flock, whether it is you know, there’s so many of them. I get a little frustrated when people think that it’s just the Flock when there’s so many different, it’s like Coke and Pepsi products, and what is the sponsor of those data collection agencies?”
Rebecca Noecker —
“I think we need to apply the same scrutiny to the other technologies that we use. So we have Axon, we have Skydio. I actually spent three hours last week in the real-time information center with the police department, and with Axon and Skydio technology experts, the people who actually, like, do the data, talking through how it works so that I could better understand it, because I’ve been getting a lot of questions about these technologies as well.”
“I was actually impressed by the number of different safeguards that they have. The problem is nobody knows about them, and there has not been an active conversation with the public to answer questions directly or to say, like they did for the body-worn cameras, what are your concerns about this and what should the right approach be?”… “I’d actually like to be able to have folks like you in the conversation with the police department, asking them the questions that I asked, and probably even better questions, because this is something that, you know, you know much more about than I do, and then figuring out together what should those guardrails be.”
Q: How would you preemptively address and dissuade future end-runs of our elected officials by private entities, such as Flock, Axon, etc., from directly engaging with law enforcement in installing their technology?
María Isa Pérez-Vega —
“Our role as advocating for ordinances and legislation that is to protect our freedoms should be highly valued by those that are in law enforcement, and so my role is to have these safeguards against what’s being misused. And the safeguard isn’t just starting with the technology; it’s starting with each individual that has been very pro of these technologies, and also may not understand like the accessibility that is actually out there due to our resources at the the hands of our own children that are studying coding in school. So overall, it can’t just be made up of a sheriff or a chief’s advisory.”
“I think that there is a need for more protection and more leadership amongst our legislators, our local electeds, our overall levels of government right now, especially what we’re dealing with, especially what we’re dealing with this federal administration that is going haywire on targeting us. As somebody who’s been a survivor of political violence in the last year, it’s really highly enclosed that we don’t want to let go of things that can protect us, but we also have to see what we’re compromising because that’s not safe either. ”
Rebecca Noecker —
“This process [removing the Flock cameras] has really helped send that message to our police department. We did not grant them the ability to apply for a grant that they were looking to get to expand the drone program because we felt like that transparency had been missing from the public.”
“Another thing that we can do is change our ordinances to spell out which contracts the city council has to approve.”
[Follow-up question: Is that true also at the level of the county, if you should get into the county board?]
“I know that the sheriff has a lot more autonomy than the police department does because he’s independently elected. That said, the county, again, controls his budget, and so I would have to imagine that they would be within their rights to at least pass a resolution saying we want, even if they can’t encode, spell that out, and maybe they can, this is some of the research that I intend to do.
Q: What does the oversight of these programs look like at the county level? In your dream world, who participates in oversight, how is this oversight communicated with the public, and what recourse would be available when these programs run afoul of this oversight?
María Isa Pérez-Vega —
“There’s aa consistent fight within my office now on overall surveillance, and I’ve been a co-author of our House version of Representative Brad Tabke on more regulations and safeguards against the misuse of these practices, of these surveillance technologies as well as have deep partnerships and conversations with Clare Oumou Verbeten in regards to how local departments, you know, we were fighting for that at the state. Our members on the other side of the aisle do not want to comply, moving it forward.”
“As a county commissioner, I will continue to advocate in opposing the uses of these surveillance cameras. There’s a step one to step two is having more conversations regarding the outside agencies [and] unauthorized parties that have been leaking our information, and how there needs to be proactivity on holding them accountable for those past tactics and how they may have continued other efforts in other forms. You know, the number one role of a leader is to make sure that you are protecting your constituents and protecting the constitutional rights and our civil liberties and our individual privacy, so I definitely will be continuing that advocacy to dismantle those contracts.”
Rebecca Noecker —
“So dream world at the county would be that whenever any one of these conversations speak at the very beginning, there’s a conversation with the county board. There’s an open information session where the sheriff in this case would present, you know, here’s the technology I want to use, here’s why I want to use it… One of the things I stated at the city council (I think the county has a form of this already, but if not, I would like to introduce it), is what’s called a “policy session” where all of the ideas about potential policies are vetted publicly before they ever proceed.”
“And then adoption with some sort of, I’m a big believer in check-in points. So, you know, after a year, let’s come back and revisit this.” …. “Because technology is evolving every second, and sow we, we can’t just say, oh, we wrote this policy a year ago, it’s exactly the same applicable policy today.”
Q: What role should the public play, in giving their consent to AI-powered mass surveillance?
María Isa Pérez-Vega —
“It’s a strength that I’m somebody that [the] majority of my work in policy is before I became a legislator and a lawmaker. It was, you know, we the people are to create the policy with those who are going to fight for it. So the advocacy of ensuring that there is consistent organizing work and spaces of usage within our own government bodies to ensure that there [are] consistent meetings. Meetings are one thing, but you need to take action, and the action comes with the public, the action is really there. The stories, the testimony. That’s why I always get a little frustrated with the capacity of sometimes people just fighting for it. And I’m like, you have to. If we don’t fight for it with the people and listen and have our public engaged in actually creating the policy with us as makers, then we shouldn’t be in leadership.”
“We can talk about it, we can say we’re about it, but I’m one that has been consistent with taking action and holding accountability to other colleagues as well as myself. You know, we’re not perfect people, but we have to listen to the people that elect us. That’s our job. The public is my boss, so if I’m not including what they deserve, what is the necessity for the overall public, you know, oversight of the surveillance, then I’m really not doing my job and I want to be a continuous voice for the people as an elected. So they are definitely the priority in creating this policy to remove these technolog[ies] that are abusing our livelihood.”
Rebecca Noecker —
“I think this goes back to the process that we follow when AI or surveillance in general is adopted in the first place. So I think the public needs to be involved. One of the things that I think can be really helpful from public facing groups, like Eyes Off, is to create the conditions and the places and the settings and the convenings where that both input and consent can be given. One of the things I find not helpful about the way our current system works is that our public hearings and our public input is done at a city council meeting.”
“What I find most helpful, especially with something as important and complicated as these topics, is actual dialogue. So, you know, and the police department can host one and council members can host one, but that’s not the same as when a community-driven group hosts a conversation like that and invites us in to be guests, not hosts. It feels really different. So I would say, I would love, one of the reasons I was really excited to get your invitation. I would love it if Eyes Off would be a group that would be helpful, maybe co-partner, co-host, etc. in convening and helping facilitate some of this community engagement that we want to do that I think is essential for us to do. And then that, that process, that discussion will guide those decisions about the formal ways for community input over time.”
